Explainer: Charting The Development of New Jersey's Charter Schools

JOHN MOONEY | SEPTEMBER 17, 2013

Charter schools are nothing if not controversial, but what's beneath the chatter?

First launched in New Jersey in 1997, charter schools have in the past five years become a hot issue in New Jersey -- both for the alternatives they provide students and districts, and the debate they have fueled over the role of public education. Charter schools are public schools operated by private nonprofit groups that are outside the governance of the local district. Instead, they are overseen by the state through a “charter” or specific renewable agreement.

Their significance

The charter movement started with just 13 schools and grew slowly during the first decade. Now numbering close to 90 schools and serving 30,000 students, they have matured into a powerful force in the state, especially in urban districts where they are concentrated. In Newark, for example, close to 20 percent of public school students are in charter schools, including a few that are among the district’s highest-performing schools. They have also sparked some backlash in both urban and suburban communities that have resisted the schools and what they call “draining” of local funds and students, as well as the lack of local say in their expansion, among other reasons. National charter management organizations have also made major inroads in the state, including the nonprofit KIPP Network and Uncommon Schools, and for-profit management firms are also now helping run two new schools in New Jersey.

Charter school funding

Much of the debate on charter schools is how they are paid for, with a local district required to pay 90 percent of the district’s per-pupil costs for each one of its students attending the charter. The formula has some exceptions, and charters contend that the average they receive is closer to 70 percent of actual per-pupil costs. Public funds are also prohibited from being used to build a charter facility, leaving schools to rely often on private fundraising or borrowing. However, public funds may be used for rent or leases, including in empty space in districts.

Charters: better, worse, or about the same as district schools?

Maybe all of the above. Depending on the study or how they are compared, charter schools are very similar to the district schools that they draw from: some are strong, some are weak, and many do about the same when it comes to test scores and other quantitative measures. True, some are exceptional in terms of student performance, far surpassing their local peers, and a recent study by Stanford University researchers -- albeit a contested one -- found that on average they outperform their local districts. But 30 out of more than 115 approved charter schools have been closed or not renewed by the state, many of them cited for financial problems and increasingly for poor performance.

 

Key debates

For all the discussions about how charters and district schools compare in student performance, much of the recent debate is on how their student enrollments compare. State law requires that charters be open to all those apply, and when demand exceeds available seats, a fair and open lottery must be held. But critics point out that despite this requirement, charters have smaller special-needs and at-risk populations than their district counterparts, bringing a new segregation within a single community. Backers say that the concern is exaggerated, and that the state holds charters to close enrollment requirements. Debates have also cropped up about charters that appear geared to specific populations, such as Hebrew or Chinese language schools, as well as those that have been proposed for special-ed students.

The Charter School Program Act of 1995

Signed by then-Gov. Christie Whitman, New Jersey’s charter school law has not seen much, if any, change in 18 years, and lawmakers have called for new act to meet the state’s changing demands and circumstances. A prime point of contention is whether to require a local vote on any new charter. Others have sought changes in how charters are funded, reviewed, and approved. A hot-button topic is whether the new law should allow for innovations such as online or virtual charters, which are now not explicitly mentioned.

Key players

  • Gov. Chris Christie and state education commissioner Chris Cerf have been big cheerleaders for charter schools, although they have lowered the number of new approvals in the past two years in the face of the local pushback and added rigor to the application process.

  • The New Jersey Charter Schools Association is headed by Carlos Perez.

  • Prominent charter school leaders include Ryan Hill, the New Jersey director of the KIPP Network, and Mashea Ashton, chief executive of the Newark Charter School Fund.

  • More critical voices have come from leaders of the New Jersey Education Association, the Education Law Center in Newark, and the Save Our Schools NJ advocacy group.

  • Rutgers education professor Bruce Baker has conducted considerable research on charter’s performance and enrollment.

  • Legislators leading the discussions about a new charter law include state Sen. Teresa Ruiz, and state Assembly members Patrick Diegnan Jr., Mila Jasey, and Troy Singleton.

Read more in EducationExplainer
Do you like this post?

Showing 2 reactions


commented 2014-07-01 03:07:45 -0700
Si vous avez été ciblez le Guess thèque mais n’ont pas eu le courage de montres guess homme gaspiller mieux une partie de votre rémunération actuelle là-bas, à côté de adjani guess est l’homme ou la femme de se rencontrer. Marque Réductions est certainement une solution innovante aux besoins de femmes qui aiment décorer intelligent et aussi dépenser judicieusement. Un magasin spécial tout au long de la collier guess coeur promotion de produits d’architecte avant-eu. Guess adjani dit que l’idée trouve votre ex lorsque votre amant réalisé votre femme a reçu des amis venant de conclut également sur la plage exactement qui peut tirer un avantage de l’autre. La jeune fille explique, nous avons copains qui veulent acheter des produits de marque tels que le aimerions consacrer ce genre de trésorerie et j’inclus aussi de bons amis qui font des emplettes classe beaucoup ne peuvent pas reconnaître où vous pouvez organiser les cinquante pour cent idées. Dans tous les cas, Guess adjani qualité supérieure sont si http://www.luxe-en-soldes.com/montres-guess.html haut prix à seule offre. Par conséquent, je suppose, si une personne peut se propager à la femme de complément d’une autre personne ne souhaite que cela pourrait être une circonstance content pour nous tous. La réputation, en plus de la conception pratiqué en Asie de l’Est, en Amérique et aussi l’Union européenne, une boutique détermine un jeans guess contrat en utilisant ces gens enthousiastes à propos de merchandising leurs propres soldes Guess. Les détaillants facturent leurs produits si vous me demandez d’obtenir un montant de quatre vingt dix jours. Beaucoup d’entre nous signions un accord qui sera poignées clauses importantes. Je ne guess femme voudrais pas acquérir tout illimité. Juste à la fin en ce qui concerne 90 jours, un paiement au propriétaire votre argent destiné à tout (a) qui a vendu en outre à ce que la réapparition a exactement pas. En cas nous avons tous deux le désir d’aller de l’avant la réelle mise en place, nous avons tous réapprovisionner la disposition réelle. Maintenant, Guess adjani mémoire Fortify porte une collection de 40 par rapport à des biens qui comprend principalement soldes de Guess. Une boutique aussi les actions et les options de solde guess femme lunettes de soleil, cravates, appareils, des chaussures ou des bottes ainsi que des tenues. Les hommes et les femmes donnent merci de nous parce que la description de la façon dont la puissance se débarrasser de leur encombrement particulier à faire de l’argent alors qu’ils ont atteint ce.
commented 2013-12-31 11:26:57 -0800
Thank you